How it works
Each challenge will focus on a new protein target representing one of five possible challenges in hit-finding, based on the type of data available:
- Protein structure in complex with a small molecule, some structure-activity relationship (SAR)
- Protein structure in complex with a small molecule, no SAR
- Apo protein structure
- No experimentally determined protein structure, some SAR
- No experimentally determined protein structure, no SAR
For each challenge, participants will be invited to use their computational methods to find hits (drug-like molecules) for a protein target selected by CACHE. CACHE will procure the molecules from commercial vendors and test them experimentally with two rigorous binding assays. Compounds from de novo design methods will be procured by participants [details]. The purity and solubility of active molecules will also be evaluated experimentally. CACHE will provide each participant with the experimental protein binding data for their prediction. Using this knowledge, participants may predict a second round of molecules that will be experimentally tested by CACHE. Additionally, the structures of all selected molecules, but not their activity, will be made available to all participants who will be asked to use their computational method to identify hits. The final evaluation process will incorporate:
- experimental hit rate
- affinity and physico-chemical properties of the hits from a participant’s selection
- hit selection from the pooled library.
A panel of experienced medicinal chemists will also comment on the hits.
Participants will be asked to disclose their approaches in sufficient detail to enable an expert in the area to understand the methodology while computational algorithms can remain proprietary. At the end of the competition, all chemical structures and associated activity from all participants will be disclosed to the public. Top-performing participants and those who wish to will be de-anonymized.
CACHE will cover costs of compound synthesis and assays in the first two challenges, up to a limit of 150 commercially available compounds per participant.
While the first two CACHE challenges are in part supported by grants, participants will be asked to contribute towards the costs of procuring and testing their selected compounds starting with challenge #3.
The access fee for entering a CACHE challenge and having compounds procured and tested is $CA40K (~US$31.5K), which includes operating costs ($CA10K) as well as compounds and consumables ($CA30K).
We encourage potential participants from academia to include these costs in their grant applications focused on the development and experimental validation of virtual screening methodologies. CACHE will support these applications, for example in the form of letter of support. Please contact us at email@example.com for details.
Disease foundations and other funders may in some cases sponsor challenges and cover the access fee for top candidates (based on the double-blind peer-review process taking place at the outset of each challenge).